The MG Album Club - #12: True Blue (Madonna)

Ojai Sam

Staff member
Madonna - True Blue (1986)

MI0002274413.jpg



We have complete confidence in your ultimate selection, despite your presently-feigned distress. :thumbsup:

We'll see how you feel after this pick. :surrender:

I enjoyed Freak's post so much that I decided to select another album based on my own back story. 1986 was a huge year for me. :heart: On February 14, my bride-to-be and I eloped by driving in a downpour from Koreatown to Santa Barbara in my Camaro Z28 H.O. When we arrived at the court house, we were serenaded with "We've Only Just Begun" performed by a pair of homeless women outside the court room.

So Madonna was Mrs. Ojai's favorite record? Well, no. Her taste at the time ran to Bach and Mozart. Still does.

After our marriage, having been an only child, I found myself with three siblings. One of my newly-minted nephews, let's call him Tony, lived nearby. He began dropping by after high school with his friends, bringing their boom boxes and musical tastes with them. Tony loved Madonna, and delighted in showing me this video based on my appreciation of vintage film:


After a lot of exposure, I began to really like this album, seeing it as a joyous escape from the disco dead end into a new realm of poppy dance music. Some critics agreed:

"True Blue is the album where Madonna truly became Madonna the Superstar -- the endlessly ambitious, fearlessly provocative entertainer who knew how to outrage, spark debates, get good reviews -- and make good music while she's at it. To complain that True Blue is calculated is to not get Madonna-- that's a large part of what she does, and she is exceptional at it, but she also makes fine music." [AMG]

Others resented being manipulated:

"Critics flock to her uneven product the way liberal arts magnas flock to investment banking--so desperate are they to connect to a zeitgeist that has nothing to do with them that they decide a little glamour and the right numbers add up to meaningful work, or at least "fun." I'm not saying her flair is pleasureless--the generosity she demands in the inexhaustible "Open Your Heart" is a two-way street and then some." [Robert Christgau]

I say fun is fun, calculated or not. Where's the party? :banana:
 
I don't even need to spin this one again. My wife was a huge Madonna fan and would play this album over and over. I can probably sing along with every song at this point. And yes, as stated above, this is when Madonna became a pop icon. Still a very fun album (this one and "Ray of Light" are my cap on Madonna's music).

OK, what the hell. I will play it again for teh memoreez. I give it 4/5 stars.,
 
I loved Madonna's first two albums, but by this one I'd gotten distracted by Talking Heads, Roxy Music or Level 42 or something. It will be a pleasure to listen to this. Good pick!
 
A delightful time capsule of 1980's pop/dance music. I had never listened to the album per se, but I knew four of the nine tracks very well from radio play and I still enjoyed them today.

Almost every track tempted me to get up and dance. It was a good opportunity to test my self-restraint, which was a side benefit.

It was interesting to go back to the days of the drum machine. And it sounds like they used a synthesizer instead of a bass guitar. No judgments on that, it's just a sign of the time this was recorded. Which I guess is a compliment. Because there are some artists where I don't enjoy listening to their 1980's output because it sounds so dated. I guess in those cases the synths and drum machines aren't used well, just used because they were cheaper. True Blue has the 1980's sound but it's still enjoyable.

I don't know the history of this or who produced it but I did wonder. It seems so clearly calculated for the dance hall, but hadn't discos faded by 1986? Nonetheless, it was fun to hear her do the dance beats she was so good at, but to merge in links to latin rhythms and 60's pop. And even in the songs that aren't experimental, they're so well done that they're a pleasure to listen to. Great rhythms, great hooks.

You can hear why she was such a pop icon in the times. It makes me wonder what she's releasing these days. But I really want to listen to her first two albums next. I hope I'm not tired of Madonna by the time I'm finished with them because I'm really curious about what she's playing these days.
 
I did not know in advance what my reaction to listening to this album would be. Most of it is familiar fare, but I do not take great pains to avoid Madonna; it just kinda sorta happens.

I listened through this release twice. Well, in actuality, and in the spirit of equanimity, I listened through one full time, and then repeated, this time starting halfway through the first song, so as to balance out Unsomnambulist. Don't ask me why; maybe I thought it was funny at first. Then again, it might be some weird OCD schtick, but I'm okay with it, and I hope you are, too.

I worked through the morning with Madonna on in the background. Nothing offended me glaringly, and nothing sparked much of a reaction. I had the fleeting glimpse that "Live to Tell" and "La Isla Bonita" were two of the better songs on the album, but I have nothing to support this perspective.

All in all, I give it :2.5: . Background music rarely goes much beyond that for me.
 
Madonna - True Blue (1986)

MI0002274413.jpg





We'll see how you feel after this pick. :surrender:
I LOVE this pick. I was with Madonna from Holiday. I only bought one or two albums/cds at the time of their release, but I liked nearly all of her songs and videos. I'm not officially participating in this thread, but I now have to listen to this album. I know it will have some of the usual filler present on Madonna's albums, but the good outweighs the mediocre.
 
Confession: before my late junior year discovery of rock and roll, my musical interest started rolling with the pop music of my first two years of high school (1982-84) with the discovery of many new artists through the early days of MTV. So the beginning of a quickly escalating phase of music purchasing started with Madonna's first two albums. By 1986's True Blue though I was a rocker and pop hits like "Papa Don't Preach" and "Open Your Heart", while a big step forward creatively for Madge, just didn't tickle my ear like earlier hits ("Borderline", "Into the Groove", "Dress You Up"). Enjoyed the title track but found "La Isla Bonita" kind of bland. Big album with lots of hits but just all right with me. Ends with a fizzle as "Love Makes the World Go Round" is trite and "Jimmy Jimmy" is just dumb. Still I realize this album is a finely crafted album by an artist venturing successfully in new directions. So given it's a "not you, it's me" kind-of-album, I'd give it :3.0:

Sam though gets several :thumbsup:'s for putting a number one 80s pop album forth (instead of going all music-nerd esoteric on us)
 
Sam though gets several :thumbsup:'s for putting a number one 80s pop album forth (instead of going all music-nerd esoteric on us)

That didn't occur to me. We could have been reviewing some independent bluegrass album from twin step-brothers on dueling washtub basses and their half-cousin who plays nose-banjo from the foothills of the upper Ohio River delta. Thank you Sam!
 
I had a couple of my usual nerdy choices in mind but decided to go refreshingly mainstream. :p

Bimeby I'll put at least one of 'em up as a Lost Classic.
 
Back
Top