Unsomnambulist
Staff member
OK, OK. I'm locking this. Use the other thread.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I agree the band was best together, but I consider the last Pink Floyd album to be The Wall. In my opinion Final Cut was a Roger Waters album that the rest of the band played on with him. And yes, Momentary Lapse was a David Gilmour album and I agree it wasn't as good as previous Pink Floyd. No argument there.
As far as solo albums go, Waters is too artsy, experimental, challenging for me. I just don't enjoy his solo work. Gilmour is more melodic and fits my choice of music better.
My apology to the Roger Waters fans among us. I probably shouldn't sacrifice an artist for a punch line.
David Gilmour remains my favorite guitarist after Hendrix. I agree that Pink Floyd was at its best with all four members (post Syd).
Syd Barrett era Pink Floyd was like a different band. A great band, but different.
How is it? Still in the 4AD category?
How is it? Still in the 4AD category?

You saw them in concert?
You saw them in concert?