Zounds! Gadzooks! Heaven forfend!
I had three big problems with the Fans' list.
1) It didn't include most of my favorites. Probably more accurate to say it included only 2 or 3 or my favorites from 1980-2020.
2) For a list ostensibly created to honor new-ish performers who maybe were not alive during the 50s-60s (especially considering albums from the 90s onward) much less active during the 50s-60s, the fans lists includes many albums by 60s holdovers. It seems like every album released by Wayne Shorter and Joe Henderson after 1980 was included. But not Hancock's "Flood" from 1975 or "Dis Is Da Drum" from 1994. Not Henderson's "Canyon Lady" from 1975 or "Barcelona" from 1980. No, nothing from when they were actually still innovating. Just the stuff that harkens back to the 50s and 60s?
3) Speaking of repeat nominations, some artists are represented way too much on the fans' list. I'm not exaggerating when I say practically every album ever released by Pat Metheny is listed. And Jaco. And Half of Brecker's and Blade's and Mehldau's albums. I had to laugh at a couple of albums - any album that honors a dead legend and the band includes 60s legends is sure to be listed. For instance, 2002's "Directions In Music" honoring Coltrane and Miles (!!) has Hancock (!!!) and Brecker (!!!) in the band, so you know that's an automatic IN. Herbie Hancock honoring Joni Mitchell? IN!
I'm not complaining that any of those albums are bad. Most are fantastic. But it just feels wrong.
Even when the fans get it right and include a younger musician who richly deserves it, like guitarist Kurt Rosenwinkel, they overdo it and include three or four of his albums. Basically, I want to accuse the fans of ballot stuffing! No way does a cult favorite like Rosenwinkel get that many albums on this list, not even as tremendous as he is.
Oh, did I mention Wayne Shorter got 2 (TWO!!!!) albums in the 2010-2019 decade? Really! I love the dude, but was there no one else to honor?

Fans is stoopid.