Wilhelm Furtwangler (Berlin Philharmonic, Vienna Philharmonic) -
Historic Wartime Archives (rec. 1942-44, Tahra 1998)
The recordings made by Wilhelm Furtwangler for German radio during WWII have appeared in various guises over the years. They were even released on Melodiya, perhaps dubbed from masters looted by the Russians after the fall of Berlin. I have posted about Furtwangler before, a stridently apolitical man who saved countless Jewish musicians and annoyed Hitler no end. Yet somehow he got tarred by the Nazi brush while far more Fuhrer-friendly figures emerged unscathed (ja, I'm talking to you, Herbert.

).
Over the past few days, I've been listening to these performances in awe as to how it was possible to coax such precise yet deeply moving performances from a group of musicians while their world was literally falling around their heads.
The crown jewel of this collection is the March 1942 version of Beethoven's 9th Symphony. Running a leisurely 73 minutes, it takes the listener on a tumultuous journey ending in the full-throated victory that would ultimately elude the Germans. Vocal duties were handled by a talented ensemble that included both Peter Anders, a pliable Nazi and Elisabeth Hongen, an Austrian who apparently steered clear of the regime.
One smug classical website calls this recording "despicable" but this is surely revisionism at its worst. Knowing what I do about Furtwangler and his highly dangerous relationship with the Nazis, I see this stunning performance as the ultimate triumph of music over evil.

on the Sam-O-Meter.
